Seafood Restaurant in Brooklyn: Raw Bar, Oysters and a Seafood Dinner in Sheepshead Bay

Joe Stone Crab Claws with lemon, melted butter and mustard sauce at Terra Brooklyn

Search for a seafood restaurant in Brooklyn and you’ll get two kinds of answers: fried-fish counters and crab-boil spots on one side, Manhattan-priced tasting menus on the other. Terra sits in between. It’s a modern European restaurant at 1716 Sheepshead Bay Road with a raw bar, a menu where the sea gets real attention, and a list of more than 240 wines chosen to sit next to it.

This guide walks through what to order at Terra if seafood is the reason you’re going out tonight: oysters and stone crab from the raw bar, starters like scallops and lobster bisque, fish and pasta mains, and the wines that suit them. You’ll also find prices, hours and a few tips for planning the evening.

Why Terra Belongs on Your List of Seafood Restaurant Brooklyn Options

Most seafood restaurants in Brooklyn build the whole evening around the catch. Terra Brooklyn works the other way: it’s a full modern European restaurant where seafood is one of the strongest threads through the menu. You can make a complete dinner from the raw bar and the fish mains, while the person across the table orders steak or duck. That flexibility is what many diners actually want when they type “seafood restaurant Brooklyn NY” into a search bar.

It also explains why Terra keeps coming up when locals talk about good seafood restaurants in Brooklyn without crossing the bridge. The plates are composed rather than piled high, the room is calm and elegant, and the wine list goes far deeper than a typical seafood spot in Brooklyn. If you’ve been looking at upscale seafood restaurants Brooklyn has to offer and want something that feels special without a Manhattan check, this is the gap Terra fills.

Terra at a glance
Address1716 Sheepshead Bay Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11235
Raw barOysters, stone crab claws, shrimp, seafood platters, ceviche
Seafood mains$32–$38
Wine listMore than 240 wines, about a dozen by the glass
DinnerTue–Thu & Sun 5–10 PM, Fri–Sat 5–11 PM

For the best seafood Brooklyn diners will find in Sheepshead Bay, start with the raw bar.

Looking for an Oyster Bar in Brooklyn? Start at Terra’s Raw Bar

Plenty of people searching for an oyster bar in Brooklyn NY really want one thing: cold, clean shellfish on ice and a glass of something crisp. Terra isn’t a dedicated oyster bar, but its raw bar delivers exactly that, as the opening act of a full dinner. It’s a raw bar restaurant experience without the standing-room crowd: you order raw bar oysters and chilled seafood at the table, then carry on into starters and mains.

The raw bar seafood selection is short and focused, and it’s served at both dinner and weekend brunch.

Raw bar dishWhat you getPrice
Seasonal OystersBeet-horseradish sauce, shallot mignonette, cocktail sauce, lemon$18 for 6, $32 for 12
Chef’s OystersCherry vinaigrette and black caviar$24 for 6, $44 for 12
Seafood PlatterSmall: 3 shrimp, 3 oysters, 1 stone crab claw. Large: 6 shrimp, 6 oysters, 2 claws$30 small, $55 large
Joe’s Stone Crab ClawsSourced from Joe’s Stone Crab in Miami, served chilled$55 medium, $65 large
Shrimp CocktailChilled shrimp with house cocktail sauce$19
Seafood CevicheTuna, octopus and shrimp in leche de tigre with avocado and a hint of chili$22

Best Oysters in Brooklyn: Seasonal Oysters or Chef’s Oysters?

If you’re chasing the best oysters Brooklyn has to offer, Terra gives you two ways to eat them. The Seasonal Oysters are the classic route. Three sauces sit on the side: a sharp beet-horseradish, a shallot mignonette and cocktail sauce, so you can taste the oyster first and season after.

The Chef’s Oysters are the dressed version. A cherry vinaigrette adds a little sweetness and acidity, and black caviar brings a salty, briny finish. Sharing? Order six of each and compare them side by side.

Seafood Platter in Brooklyn: The Easiest Way to Share

The Seafood Platter is the move for two or more people who can’t decide. The small platter covers a couple, the large feeds a table, and both combine shrimp, oysters and stone crab. For a seafood platter in Brooklyn at $30, it’s also an easy way to try the raw bar before committing to a dozen oysters.

Stone Crab, Shrimp Cocktail and Ceviche at the Raw Bar in Brooklyn

Stone crab claws aren’t something you find on every raw bar in Brooklyn. Terra’s come from Joe’s Stone Crab in Miami and are served chilled, in medium or large. For something brighter, the Seafood Ceviche mixes tuna, octopus and shrimp in leche de tigre, while the Shrimp Cocktail keeps things simple. Visitors comparing a Brooklyn oyster bar with a sit-down dinner often end up doing both here: raw bar first, then the kitchen.

Seafood Starters, Soup and Salads

After the raw bar, the starters are where Terra’s kitchen starts to show its style. They’re built for sharing, and two or three of them can easily stand in for a main course.

Salmon Two Ways and Scallops Under Smoke

Salmon appears twice. Terra Gravlax is dill-cured salmon on a crisp hash brown with cucumber, sesame oil and lime ($20). Salmon Tartare is hand-cut and mixed with avocado, citrus and a hint of chili ($25), the lighter and brighter of the two.

Scallops à la Mar ($26) is the table’s show moment. Seared scallops sit on pea and mint purée with raspberry foam and black caviar, and arrive under a dome filled with smoke. We describe it in more detail in our guide to Terra’s signature dishes.

Lobster Bisque, Mussels and the Crab Roll

If you want something warm, the Lobster Bisque ($20) comes with lobster meat and zucchini under a golden puff pastry crust, finished with black caviar. Guests mention it often in reviews. Paola, who dined with her husband, put it simply:

“I was intrigued by the lobster soup… Both were delicious.”

Mussels en Rouge ou Blanc ($18) come steamed in your choice of Napoli or white sauce, with basil-garlic bread for the broth. The Crab Roll ($27) is the most casual plate of Brooklyn seafood on the menu: crab with the house sauce and caviar on a brioche bun, with fries and truffle aioli.

Octopus and Shrimp Salads

Two salads lean toward the sea. Octopus ($22) is grilled and served with roasted baby potatoes, tomatoes and roasted peppers. Avocado with Shrimp ($20) pairs poached shrimp with cucumber tartare and citrus. As Vitalii wrote after his visit:

“The octopus salad was fresh and well-balanced.”

Seafood Mains: Fish, Shrimp and Squid-Ink Pasta

The mains are where Terra stops being just a raw bar stop and becomes a proper fish restaurant Brooklyn diners can build a whole evening around. There are four seafood entrées, two built around fish and two around pasta.

Seafood mainOn the platePrice
HalibutRoasted cauliflower, marinated watermelon radish, citrus-ginger sauce$34
Herb SalmonHerb crust, creamy spinach, red caviar crème blanche$38
Linguine di MareSquid-ink linguine, shrimp, mussels, calamari, spicy coconut Tom Yum sauce$32
Shrimp LimoneHomemade spinach pasta, tiger shrimp, creamy lemon sauce, red caviar$32

Halibut and Herb Salmon at a Seafood Restaurant in Brooklyn

The Halibut is the lightest of the mains. A mild white fillet meets roasted cauliflower, marinated watermelon radish and a citrus-ginger sauce that keeps every bite fresh. The Herb Salmon is richer, with a herb crust, creamy spinach and a red caviar crème blanche. Both show what you can expect from a seafood restaurant in Brooklyn that cooks with a European accent.

Linguine di Mare and Shrimp Limone

For pasta, the two dishes go in very different directions. Linguine di Mare tosses black squid-ink pasta with shrimp, mussels and calamari in a spicy coconut Tom Yum sauce, the boldest flavors on the seafood side of the menu. Shrimp Limone is gentler: homemade spinach pasta with tiger shrimp in a creamy lemon sauce, finished with red caviar.

Not everyone at the table wants fish? The dinner menu also has an 18 oz prime ribeye, filet mignon and braised veal cheeks. If you’re planning a surf-and-turf evening, our guide to steak in Brooklyn covers the meat side, and the full dinner menu has everything in one place.

A Seafood Restaurant in Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn NY

Sheepshead Bay has a long relationship with the sea. Fishing boats still line the piers along Emmons Avenue, and the bay has been a destination for seafood lovers for generations. So it makes sense that people search for a seafood restaurant in Sheepshead Bay before anywhere else in South Brooklyn.

Terra isn’t on the water. It’s on Sheepshead Bay Road, a few minutes from the bay, which makes an easy evening plan: walk the piers at sunset, then head up the road for oysters and halibut. Our guide to things to do in Sheepshead Bay maps out that route, from the piers to the footbridge.

Among seafood restaurants in Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, Terra stands out for pairing a raw bar with a serious wine program. Guests have called it the best restaurant in Sheepshead Bay for a special dinner, and the wine list is a big part of that story. You can read why in Sheepshead Bay Restaurants: Why Terra Brings a Serious Wine List to South Brooklyn. If you’re still comparing places to eat in Sheepshead Bay and the neighborhoods around it, our guide to restaurants near Sheepshead Bay puts Sheepshead Bay, Brighton Beach and Manhattan Beach side by side.

Wine with Seafood at Terra

With more than 240 wines on the list, seafood never has to settle for a generic house white. By the glass, the Raventós i Blanc Blanc de Blancs Cava ($17) and G. Tribaut Champagne ($26) cut through the brine of oysters. Gaia Monograph Assyrtiko from Greece ($11) and Inama Soave Classico ($12) suit ceviche, salmon tartare and the halibut. Florent Cosme Vouvray ($13) has the texture for scallops and lobster bisque.

For a bottle, Chablis is the classic match for the raw bar: try Domaine Laroche Saint Martin ($81) or Daniel Dampt Premier Cru ‘Les Vaillons’ ($93). Do Ferreiro Albariño from Rías Baixas ($78) and Ameztoi Txakoli ($64) bring Atlantic freshness, while Paul Prieur Sancerre ($75) works with salmon and shrimp. Our wine and caviar pairing guide explains why Chablis does so well with scallops and caviar. The full wine list is online.

You don’t need to know any of this in advance. Viktoriya summed up her experience:

“Extensive wine list with great wine selection… even offered wine tasting to make sure the wine we chose was to our liking and expectations.”

Seafood at Weekend Brunch

The raw bar isn’t only for dinner. On Saturdays and Sundays from 11 AM to 3 PM, oysters, the Seafood Platter and stone crab claws are on the brunch menu, alongside a Lobster Salad ($22), Zucchini Crêpes with smoked salmon ($16) and the Grand Benedict with smoked salmon ($19). Bojkena came for a Sunday brunch and wrote:

“We ordered oysters as appetizers and they tasted Divine, very fresh.”

For a full rundown, see Brunch in Sheepshead Bay: What to Order and our guide to brunch wine for eggs, pancakes and seafood.

How to Plan a Seafood Dinner at Terra

If you’ve been searching “seafood restaurant Brooklyn near me” or “raw bar restaurants near me” from anywhere in South Brooklyn, Terra is easy to reach at 1716 Sheepshead Bay Road. Dinner is served Tuesday through Thursday and Sunday from 5 to 10 PM, and Friday and Saturday from 5 to 11 PM. The bar opens at 4 PM, so you can start with a glass of Champagne before the kitchen begins dinner service.

A seafood dinner for two might look like this: a small Seafood Platter or six Chef’s Oysters to open, the Scallops à la Mar or Lobster Bisque to share, then Halibut and Linguine di Mare as mains. Add a bottle of Chablis or Albariño, and you have the kind of evening people mean when they look for the best seafood restaurant Brooklyn can offer, without a trip into Manhattan.

Booking ahead is the easiest way to get the table you want, especially on weekends. Reserve through our reservations page. Groups larger than 12 should call (718) 675-3939. Before you come, you can browse the full Terra menu for breakfast, brunch and dinner.

FAQ

What is a raw bar?

A raw bar is the part of a restaurant menu dedicated to chilled, mostly uncooked seafood served on ice: oysters, clams, shrimp, crab and similar. At Terra, the raw bar includes Seasonal and Chef’s Oysters, Joe’s Stone Crab claws, Shrimp Cocktail, Seafood Ceviche and Seafood Platters.

Is Terra an oyster bar in Brooklyn?

Terra is a modern European restaurant with a raw bar, not a dedicated oyster bar. You can come just for oysters and a glass of wine, or order them as the start of a full seafood dinner.

What is the best seafood restaurant in Brooklyn for a special occasion?

The best seafood restaurants in Brooklyn for a celebration combine fresh shellfish, cooked dishes and a good wine list. In Sheepshead Bay, Terra offers all three: a raw bar, seafood mains like halibut and herb-crusted salmon, and more than 240 wines.

How much are oysters at Terra?

Seasonal Oysters are $18 for six and $32 for twelve. Chef’s Oysters with cherry vinaigrette and black caviar are $24 for six and $44 for twelve.

Can I order seafood at brunch?

Yes. On weekends from 11 AM to 3 PM, the raw bar is on the brunch menu, along with Lobster Salad, Zucchini Crêpes with smoked salmon and a smoked-salmon Grand Benedict.

Where is Terra located?

Terra is a seafood restaurant in Brooklyn, New York, at 1716 Sheepshead Bay Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11235, just up the road from the bay. Call (718) 675-3939 or book online.

Does Terra serve dishes other than seafood?

Yes. The dinner menu also includes an 18 oz prime ribeye, filet mignon, braised veal cheeks, duck confit, Wagyu burgers and vegetarian dishes like Beetroot Ravioli and Mushroom Risotto.

Reserve Your Seafood Dinner in Sheepshead Bay

Oysters on ice, stone crab, halibut and a glass of Chablis are waiting at Terra, a seafood restaurant in Brooklyn worth the trip to Sheepshead Bay. Reserve your table for dinner tonight or brunch this weekend. We look forward to welcoming you.